Students, Brains, and Science

Written by: Patrick McGurrin

show/hide words to know

Close-ended: a type of question that limits the person responding to a small number of choices. An example is a multiple-choice question.

Nervous system: organ system made of a network of specialized cells called neurons that coordinate the actions of an animal and transmit signals to and from different parts of the body... more

Neuroscience: a part of biology that studies the brain and the nervous system.

Open-ended: a type of question that lets a person write out her or his own answer. An example is a short answer question.

Sample size: the number of people or animals involved in an experiment.

Survey: a process used to collect data, like facts or opinions, from a group of people to try to estimate what the responses might be from a larger group of people.

What’s in the Story?

A blue glow becomes brighter with each step as you walk down a dimly lit hallway. You enter an open room with a huge glass wall. Behind it, fish of every shape and size cruise through the water. You stand for a while with your face pressed to the glass to see little crabs scurry across rocks and sand as they move about the tank floor. As you are about to move on to the next room of the aquarium the color of a rock changes. And… it has tentacles?

fish swim through an aquarium. A large clam sits in the bottom right of the image, surrounded by coral and rocks. Above the aquarium floor brightly colored fish swim about the tank.

If you look around an aquarium tank, you may not see all the animals at once. This is because many animals that live underwater are good at blending in with their surroundings. Image by meowmeow10.

An octopus has been hiding right in front of you, and you watch in disbelief as it propels itself across the tank to a patch of coral. In an instant it has changed its color to match the bright coral and it disappears before your eyes. 

You scratch your head and think to yourself – “how did it do that?” Octopuses must be very smart creatures to be able to hide so well in their surroundings. Knowing that the brain is what allows people to do things like think and make decisions, you start to wonder if maybe octopuses have brains too. And if they have a brain, then what other animals may also have brains? 

As it turns out, scientists are becoming more interested in knowing what students think about brains. In the PLOS ONE article “"Do Octopuses Have a Brain?" Knowledge, Perceptions and Attitudes towards Neuroscience at School,” scientists explored what students of different ages understood about the brain. This included both what the brain does, and what types of living things have a brain.

Studying Knowledge

You might already know that we can study the nervous system. That subject is called neuroscience. But did you know that we can also study the study of the nervous system? In other words, we can study how people think about neuroscience. This is important because neuroscience has become a very large focus for scientists in the last 10 years. Because of this, many neuroscientists wonder what non-scientists think and understand about this new and growing field.

In this experiment, scientists created a survey to help them understand students' knowledge and interest in neuroscience. A survey is a list of specific questions that can be used to help learn what people know about a subject. Questions on the survey were all about neuroscience, including 12 close-ended questions and 1 open-ended question:

Q1 What is the brain for?
Q2 What is your brain doing now?
Q3 Do the different parts of the brain perform different functions?
Q4 The brain is mostly made of...
Q5 What makes you feel fear?
Q6 What makes you act courageously?
Q7 How have you learned what you know and can do today?
Q8 Only humans have a brain?
Q9 What other living species do have a brain?
Q10 A cat or a dog is able to...
Q11 What does it mean to have consciousness?
Q12 Which of the following has consciousness?

 

Scientists gave the survey to 508 students in grades 3 through 10. This large sample size helped them get data from many students, giving the scientists a solid understanding of student knowledge of neuroscience. When looking at the survey responses, scientists created three groups based on the students' ages. These included elementary (grades 3-5), middle (grades 6-8), and high school (grades 9-10). After collecting the responses, the scientists compared how students in each grade answered the survey questions.

The Brain Game

Think about what your brain is doing right now. You’re reading this page and making sense of it. But your brain is also helping you do things like using your muscles to sit upright and to move the computer mouse with your hand. Scientists found that when they asked students what their brains were doing while they were answering questions, few thought that their brains were doing things like helping their hearts to pump or their lungs to move to help them breathe. 

Scientists also asked students whether they thought the brain was important for feeling different emotions. You’re excited about the weekend, or anxious about an upcoming test. But where do those feelings come from? Most students answered correctly that the brain is where these feelings come from, but others reported that they may come from other places too, like the blood and heart. 

Who Has a Brain?

Brain control graph

Scientists were interested in what students believed the brain controls. Click for more detail.

It is common to think that only certain living things, like humans, have brains. But many other living things also have brains that help them to do different jobs to help them survive. For example, octopuses have a brain and use it to change colors and shapes to make them look similar to what they see in their surroundings. This helps them to hide from predators.

So what other living things have brains? Scientists asked students this question and included choices like bees, sharks, chimps, and octopuses. Most of the students believed that animals like horses and chimps have brains, but other species like octopuses and bees do not. But all of these animals have a brain. And as it turns out, octopuses might be some of the smartest animals on the planet. 

Survey Says…

many brownish-red ants are together on top of a leaf-like structure. They are working together to carry a larger object, which is another bug of some kind. It is larger than the ants and black in color.

These weaver ants use their brains to work together to carry a larger bug. Image by Evdaimo.

When they looked over all the answers, scientists concluded that students had some understanding of the brain, but their knowledge was not complete. For example, students were able to understand the basic anatomy of the brain, such as its location in the body and that it's made of neurons.

But students didn't seem to understand two key things. The first was information about how the brain works. For example, how do neurons talk to each other to help us feel emotion and hunger?

The second was how the human brain works in comparison to the brains of other species. Do we have the same brain parts, and do those parts have the same functions? Students tended to think that other animals could not do complex things like humans can. 

What Would You Like to Know? 

Animal brains graph

Students were asked whether different animals had brains like humans do. Click for more detail.

If you could find out anything about the brain, what would it be? Through this open-ended part of the survey, students reported to be most interested in learning about the different parts of the brain and how they work to help us to be smart and remember things. Other students were curious about how the brain develops and whether it’s true that we only use 10% of our brain. It turns out that we use all of our brain, but development causes each person or animal’s brain to be unique. 

Scientists learned that students are definitely curious about neuroscience but still don’t have a great understanding of how the brain works. Maybe this is because of the way neuroscience is taught in school, and in what grade students begin to learn about this topic.

Overall, scientists concluded that neuroscience should be taught to students earlier in school to improve understanding of the topic. They also thought neuroscience should be taught in a more comparative way. This means that teachers would compare different species to explore what we know about brains in general. This type of approach would allow students to understand the brains of both different animals and those of humans. 


Additional Images via Wikimedia Commons. MRI image by Ranveig. Blue-ringed octopus image by Jnpet.

View Citation

You may need to edit author's name to meet the style formats, which are in most cases "Last name, First name."

Bibliographic details:

  • Article: Students, Brains, and Science
  • Author(s): Patrick McGurrin
  • Publisher: Arizona State University School of Life Sciences Ask A Biologist
  • Site name: ASU - Ask A Biologist
  • Date published: August 7, 2015
  • Date accessed: June 23, 2018
  • Link: https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/students-brains-and-science

APA Style

Patrick McGurrin. (2015, August 07). Students, Brains, and Science. ASU - Ask A Biologist. Retrieved June 23, 2018 from https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/students-brains-and-science

American Psychological Association. For more info, see http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/560/10/

Chicago Manual of Style

Patrick McGurrin. "Students, Brains, and Science". ASU - Ask A Biologist. 07 August, 2015. https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/students-brains-and-science

MLA 2017 Style

Patrick McGurrin. "Students, Brains, and Science". ASU - Ask A Biologist. 07 Aug 2015. ASU - Ask A Biologist, Web. 23 Jun 2018. https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/students-brains-and-science

Modern Language Association, 7th Ed. For more info, see http://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/747/08/
An octopus holding a shell
Octopuses are very smart. Some will use their tentacles to carry shells around with them to use as protection. When a predator or other threat is detected it will quickly close the shell to escape any danger.

Be Part of
Ask A Biologist

By volunteering, or simply sending us feedback on the site. Scientists, teachers, writers, illustrators, and translators are all important to the program. If you are interested in helping with the website we have a Volunteers page to get the process started.

Donate icon  Contribute

Share this page:

 

Share to Google Classroom