Cognition: a mental process that lets you think and understand things...more
Genre: a grouping or category of items that can include similarities, look, and subject matter. Some movie genres are mystery, horror, comedy, science fiction.
Mathematical model: a description of a specific relationship or system that is made using equations and can be used to define existing situations or to test hypothetical situations.
Statistics: a part of mathematics involving the collection, organization, and understanding of information based on numbers... more
Lily turns up the volume when she listens to rock. She taps her foot to the boom of the drums and bass notes. She enjoys music with unpredictable sounds and has fun finding patterns in the beat. Her brother Daniel prefers softer sounds. He likes to listen to gentle melodies in a quiet room. He daydreams as the lyrics and tune drift through his earphones. Lily likes to belt out the notes of a powerful punk rock song. Daniel prefers to let the meaning of the lyrics guide his thoughts.
Are you like Lily or Daniel? Or are you somewhere in between? You’ve got your own, unique style when it comes to music, food, sports, and clothes. But did you know you also have a style of thinking? In the PLOS One article “Musical Preferences Are Linked to Cognitive Styles”, scientists studied the link between the music we like and the way we think.
Cognition is a complex brain process through which we gain information and knowledge about the world. In other words, cognition is thinking. Scientists in this experiment tested people for two different cognitive styles or "brain types." These brain types are called "empathizing" and "systemizing."
Have you ever played an instrument? You may have noticed that in some ways, music is like math. Notes can be played for different lengths of time, at high or low pitches, and in any order. Most songs have repeating verses and choruses that have specific patterns of sounds. For instance, you might hear the ba-dum of the drums in the background as the singer belts out two high notes and then a low one. If you think mathematically by finding logic in the world, you are a "systemizer" or "Type S.”
Songs can make us feel powerful emotions. Some songs make us feel strong enough to take on the world, while others bring us to tears. Before a big exam, you might turn on a pop song with peppy lyrics and an upbeat rhythm. If you don’t get the grade you had hoped, you might pick a sad tune with a slow, calm melody. With a more emotion-based brain type, you are an "empathizer" or "Type E." Empathizers have strong empathy and are good at understanding their own feelings and the emotions of others around them. If you are an empathizer, you react to other's feelings, comforting friends when they're sad or celebrating with them when they're happy.
Using two multiple-choice tests, scientists measured people as either Type E (empathizers) or Type S (systemizers). People equally good at empathizing and systemizing are "Type B" or "balanced" thinkers.
Next, scientists had the people of these three brain types listen to music. Scientists also wanted to know what "psychological" and "sonic" aspects of music people liked. Psychological aspects of music are the ways music makes us think and feel. For instance, music can be thrilling, relaxing, sad, or thoughtful. Sonic aspects of music are the specific sounds and instruments in songs. This includes guitars, drums, and bass as well as the loudness and speed of the music.
In this study, scientists found that empathizers and systemizers prefer different psychological and sonic aspects of music. For psychological attributes, empathizers were interested in sad, gentle, relaxing, and thoughtful music. Systemizers chose thrilling, animated party music.
For sonic attributes, empathizers like instrumental music (songs without words) and songs with acoustic guitars. Systemizers enjoy loud music with heavy bass and drums, and they like electric guitars more than acoustic ones.
In general, empathizers like music such as soft rock, R&B, and soul. Systemizers prefer songs that are of the heavy metal, punk and hard rock types. Both empathizers and systemizers enjoyed all other types of music.
From this study, we learn that the way we think relates to the music we like. But which one is the cause and which is the effect? Does our brain type change our music style, or does the music we like change the way we think? It could be one of these, or it could even be both!
Scientists believe listening to certain types of music could make you more empathetic. Test this for yourself at home. Does the music you listen to change your mood? Maybe you feel happiest when you listen to upbeat music.
Although songs can be private and personal, music can also be a social experience. In fact, studies show that we bond and create friendships when we make music with others. Do you feel like music is best enjoyed in a group? Do you and your friends like to listen and sing along to songs together?
What about your thinking style? Are you an empathizer, a systemizer, or somewhere in between? Can you think of something other than brain type that could be related to the music we like?
For instance, studies have shown that personality types also influence our taste in music. Even a person's gender relates to what music they like.
Men are more likely to enjoy loud, fast, exciting music, while women tend to like more relaxing, instrumental music. This might be because men are more likely to be systemizers. Women are more often empathizers. But there are exceptions to every rule.
Brain type, personality, and gender probably aren't the end of the story. There could be many other factors that influence our favorite music that scientists haven't studied yet. Sometimes, answering questions creates even more questions. That's what science is all about!
It you want to help scientist learn more about music and personality. You can fill out this online survey - www.musicaluniverse.org. Please note that you must be 18 or older to participate.
Woman Thinking via Creative Commons
Music Notes by Marek Vanco via Dreamstime
Annika Vannan. (2017, June 30). What’s the Link Between Music and Your Brain?. ASU - Ask A Biologist. Retrieved January 21, 2021 from https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/brain-music
Annika Vannan. "What’s the Link Between Music and Your Brain?". ASU - Ask A Biologist. 30 June, 2017. https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/brain-music
Annika Vannan. "What’s the Link Between Music and Your Brain?". ASU - Ask A Biologist. 30 Jun 2017. ASU - Ask A Biologist, Web. 21 Jan 2021. https://askabiologist.asu.edu/plosable/brain-music
Does your brain dictate what music you like? Image by Wuhuiru55 in Wikimedia Commons.